Welcome to Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant
Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant, located in Staten Island, offers a taste of nostalgia with their perfectly cooked pizzas that remind customers of 90s cartoon classics like TMNT. The medium cheese pizza is a standout, described as flawless by regulars. The separate dining area provides ample seating, ensuring a comfortable dining experience. Customers rave about the grandma slice and the vodka chicken slice, highlighting the variety and quality of the menu. With consistent, delicious food and efficient service, Cafe Milano has cemented itself as a local favorite for pizza lovers. I highly recommend trying their grandma pie for a satisfying and tasty meal.
-
401 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, United States401 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, United States Hotline: +1 718-720-1313
Welcome to Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant, a hidden gem located at 401 Forest Ave in Staten Island, NY. This cozy eatery offers a delightful combination of Italian cuisine and mouthwatering pizzas that will leave you coming back for more.
From their perfectly cooked medium cheese pizzas to their delectable sandwiches, Cafe Milano is a go-to spot for those craving a taste of nostalgia. Customers rave about the quality of the food, with many highlighting the tasty grandma slices and the legendary vodka chicken slice.
One customer described the experience as akin to tasting 90s cartoon pizza, bringing back memories of classics like Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and A Goofy Movie. The atmosphere is casual yet classy, making it a great spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family.
With amenities like outdoor seating, full bar, and gender-neutral restrooms, Cafe Milano caters to a diverse range of tastes and preferences. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite to go or a leisurely dining experience, this establishment offers something for everyone.
So why not give Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant a try and indulge in a culinary journey that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more?
Ever wondered what 90s cartoon pizza tasted like (TMNT, Goofy Movie)? This is what I'd imagine. Medium cheese comes out perfect. My go to spot.
Pretty good pizza place. Love the sandwiches and their pizza is yummy!! Thanks for the good food!
Stopped by for a bite to eat on a Monday afternoon and the place was pretty quiet. There is a separate dining area next to the pizzeria so there's plenty of seating to go around. I ordered a square slice ($3.55) to go and the dough was quite puffy and soft. The mozzarella cheese tasted a little congealed so I would have liked for the slice to be warmed up a little more. Would definitely go back to try a grandma slice, but I am told their vodka chicken slice is phenomenal.
Fresh, crunchy, delicious, and delivered HOT!! Super easy to order online. Husband actually received their menu from the Cafe Milano delivery driver while he was delivering pizza to one of our neighbors. We happened to be on the lookout for a new pizza place to call our own - and we found it. Thank you!! Will absolutely order from again.
Cafe Milano makes a great grandma slice. In general, their pizza is always tasty and crisp. They also sell pretty decent subs and pastas. There's usually a line inside, but it moves fast, since the service is quick.
We love Milano's! We order from here usually once a week and have never had an issue! The food is consistent and always tastes great! Their grandma pie is my personal favorite! I did eat in the restaurant once for their buffet lunch and it was quite delicious. The restaurant was nice and clean and the service was great! Thank you for being our local favorite! We will definitely keep coming back!